Navigating the Legal Landscape of Informal 'Tanda' Savings Clubs in Ecuador: An Expert's Warning

As an expat in Ecuador, integrating into the local culture often means engaging with community financial practices. Among these, informal savings clubs—known locally as tandas, susus, or sometimes cadenas—are prevalent. These rotating savings and credit associations (ROSCAs) present a seemingly simple way to save or access lump sums of money within a trusted group. While the spirit of mutual support is admirable, as a legal professional practicing in Ecuador, I must meticulously outline the significant and often underestimated legal risks of participating in these informal arrangements. This analysis is designed to provide you with the foresight necessary to protect your financial well-being and avoid severe, unintended legal consequences.

What are 'Tanda' Savings Clubs?

At their core, tandas function on a principle of collective saving and cyclical distribution. A group of individuals contributes a fixed amount of money at regular intervals (e.g., $100 weekly). Each week, one member receives the entire pooled sum (the "pot"). The order of distribution is typically set by lottery or mutual agreement at the outset. This system is popular for those who find it difficult to save or who need a lump sum for a specific purpose without resorting to a formal loan.

The Legal Vacuum: Where Informal Agreements Meet Ecuadorian Law

The fundamental risk lies in the complete lack of formal legal recognition for these clubs. Ecuadorian law is built upon regulated financial entities and formal, notarized contracts. Tandas operate entirely outside this framework, placing them in a precarious legal grey area that borders on illegality, especially for the organizer.

The primary governing legislation for financial activities is the Código Orgánico Monetario y Financiero (COMYF). This comprehensive code, along with oversight from the Superintendencia de Bancos (for banks) and the Superintendencia de Economía Popular y Solidaria (SEPS) (for cooperatives), strictly regulates any entity that captures money from the public with the intent to place it with third parties. By design, tandas circumvent every single one of these prudential regulations.

Specific Risks Exposed: A Practitioner's Analysis

Let's move beyond theory to the concrete risks you face:

Criminal Liability for the Organizer (Captación Ilegal de Dinero):
- The Scenario: You decide to organize a tanda for your friends and neighbors to foster community. You collect the money and manage the payouts.
- Legal Implications: This is the single greatest risk. Under Artículo 145 of the COMYF, any person or entity that engages in financial activities without authorization from the relevant superintendency is conducting an illegal operation. This act, known as "captación ilegal de dinero" (illegal capturing of money), is not just a civil infraction; it is a serious crime. Artículo 323 of the Código Orgánico Integral Penal (COIP) sanctions this offense with a prison sentence of five to seven years. As the organizer, you are the person "capturing" the funds, exposing yourself to potential criminal prosecution, even if your intentions were entirely honorable.
Zero Legal Recourse in Case of Default or Fraud:
- The Scenario: A member receives their payout early in the cycle and then disappears or simply stops making their weekly contributions. The group collapses, and those at the end of the list lose all their money.
- Legal Implications: You have no effective legal remedy. While you could theoretically initiate a lawsuit for debt collection, the path is fraught with obstacles. You would likely need to use a procedimiento monitorio under the Código Orgánico General de Procesos (COGEP). However, your case would rely on a verbal agreement, which is notoriously difficult to prove in court. You would need witnesses—the other members—who are often reluctant to get involved in a formal legal dispute with a neighbor or friend. The trust that formed the group often prevents its members from testifying against one another.
The Futility of "Informal" Written Agreements:
- The Scenario: To add a layer of security, the group drafts and signs a simple document outlining the rules.
- Experience-Based Insight: While better than nothing, this document has minimal legal weight. To make it slightly more official, you could have each member sign a declaración juramentada (sworn statement) before a notary, acknowledging their debt to the group. A notary in Cuenca or Guayaquil will typically charge around $40-$50 for such a document. However, even with this, enforcement remains difficult and costly, and it does not legitimize the underlying activity in the eyes of financial regulators. It is a weak shield against a determined defaulter.
The "Friend of a Friend" Dilution of Trust:
- A Common Mistake: Expats often join a tanda through one or two close, trusted local friends. However, a ten-person tanda inevitably includes friends-of-friends and distant acquaintances whom you do not know. A common failure point I've seen in my practice occurs when one of these unknown members defaults, and your direct friend, who vouched for them, lacks the financial means to cover the loss. The chain of trust is only as strong as its weakest, most distant link.
No Regulatory Protection or Oversight:
- The Issue: Regulated institutions like banks and cooperativas de ahorro y crédito are subject to rigorous audits, capital reserve requirements, and consumer protection laws enforced by the SEPS or Superintendencia de Bancos. There is deposit insurance up to a certain limit via COSEDE.
- Impact on Tandas: A tanda has none of these protections. The organizer is not required to be solvent, financially literate, or transparent. If they mismanage, commingle, or abscond with the funds, your money is gone with no institutional safety net to fall back on.

The Superior, Legal Alternative: Cooperativas de Ahorro y Crédito

For expats seeking community-oriented finance, Ecuador's robust system of Cooperativas de Ahorro y Crédito is the ideal solution. These institutions are:

Legally Chartered: Regulated and supervised by the SEPS.
Community-Focused: They operate as member-owned cooperatives, often serving specific communities or professional groups, retaining the community feel of a tanda.
Secure: Deposits are insured, and they offer formal savings products (ahorro programado) and small loans with clear, legally enforceable terms.
A Real-World Example: Joining a reputable local cooperativa like JEP (Juventud Ecuatoriana Progresista) or Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito Santa Ana allows you to build a formal credit history in Ecuador, something a tanda can never provide.

⚠️ Legal Alert: When to Immediately Consult an Attorney

Seek professional legal counsel if:

You are asked to organize or manage a tanda. The criminal liability risk is too high to bear.
A dispute has arisen, and you are facing a significant financial loss.
You are being pressured to join a tanda involving sums that are substantial to you (e.g., over a few hundred dollars).
Someone in the group is promising returns or benefits beyond the simple rotation of funds—this is a massive red flag for a pyramid scheme disguised as a tanda.

Conclusion: Prioritize Legal Security in Your Ecuadorian Journey

The community spirit behind tandas is a cornerstone of Ecuadorian culture. However, from a legal and risk management perspective, these informal clubs represent an unacceptable financial risk. The absence of legal recourse for participants and, more alarmingly, the potential for criminal charges against organizers, makes them a practice to be avoided.

As an expat, your financial security should be paramount. By choosing regulated financial channels like the excellent network of cooperativas, you can achieve your savings goals, engage with the community, and build a secure financial future in Ecuador, all while being fully protected by the law.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

Ready to ensure your financial activities in Ecuador are legally sound and secure? Schedule a consultation to discuss your specific situation and explore compliant, protected financial solutions.